California hospital chain going to court over high prices

Loading...

One of California’s largest hospital systems is facing a trial over accusations that it has used its market dominance to snuff out competition and overcharge patients for medical bills.

Opening arguments begin Thursday in the antitrust case against Sutter Health, which operates 24 hospitals with 5, 500 doctors across Northern California. It was first brought by employers and unions amid growing frustration over the rising cost of health care in 2014; California’s attorney general, Xavier Becerra, filed a similar suit last year following a six-year DOJ investigation.

“We’re alleging that Sutter Health Systems is offering care at a higher price and perhaps even undermining quality by the way it goes about doing its business, ” Becerra said in a briefing ahead of last month’s jury selection. “And that’s not only not fair, but we believe and we allege it is against the law. ”

“Bottom line, ” Becerra said, “the public is being ripped off. ”

The trial is expected to last months. The lawsuit points to research showing that health care costs in Northern California are higher than elsewhere in the state, including a 2018 study that found unadjusted inpatient procedure prices are 70% higher in Northern California than Southern California.

“Much of the increased cost of health care in Northern California is attributable to Sutter” the AG alleges in a 49-page complaint that details a range of anticompetitive practices it says the Sacramento-based nonprofit has pursued as it gobbled up competition.

In the 1990s, Sutter embarked on “a deliberate strategy” to gain market power in certain geographic areas through a campaign of mergers and acquisitions, the parties allege, noting that Sutter’s assets rose to $15. 6 billion in 2016 from $6. 4 billion in 2005.

Sutter Health denies the claims, saying it faces fierce competition across the San Francisco Bay Area and the Sacramento Valley and insurance companies are to blame for pushing up costs.

“Sutter Health looks forward to demonstrating in court why its integrated care model promotes competition and, most importantly, benefits patients and communities, ” Sutter spokeswoman Amy Thoma Tan said in a statement. She said the largest health insurance companies support the lawsuit.

“Insurance companies want to maximize profits by pushing insurance plans that limit their choices and result in surprise billing, ” Thoma Tan said.

At issue are several of Sutter Health’s contracting policies that Becerra says have allowed the company to “thoroughly immunize itself from price competition. ”

One way insurance companies keep costs down is to steer patients to cheaper health care providers through a variety of incentives. Becerra says Sutter Health bans insurance companies from using these incentives, making it harder for patients to use their lower-priced competitors.

Becerra also says Sutter has an “all or nothing” approach to negotiating with insurance companies, requiring them to include all the company’s hospitals in their provider networks even if it doesn’t make financial sense to do so.

The case was originally filed in 2014 by a group of self-funded employers and picked up steam last year when Becerra filed a similar lawsuit and the cases were combined.

Becerra’s lawsuit seeks to halt Sutter’s alleged practices and does not seek monetary damages. But the private litigation brought by a class of about 1, 400 self-funded employers seeks damages that could exceed $1 billion.

It’s rare for antitrust lawsuits of this size to go to trial. Atrium Health, a North Carolina-based hospital system, settled a similar anti-trust lawsuit with the federal government last year. And CHI Franciscan, a health system based in Washington state, also settled similar claims in March that had been brought by the state.

1,349 Comments

  1. ปั้มไลค์ October 10, 2019
  2. Keanu October 13, 2019
  3. generic viagra sales January 7, 2020
  4. viagra uk January 12, 2020
  5. cialis.com January 14, 2020
  6. cialis 10mg January 17, 2020
  7. generic viagra canada January 17, 2020
  8. generic viagra 100mg January 17, 2020
  9. centforce 100 January 20, 2020
  10. best kratom strains January 21, 2020
  11. careprost buy online January 22, 2020
  12. cialis price January 22, 2020
  13. can i buy viagra online February 3, 2020
  14. generic viagra February 17, 2020
  15. online cialis generic February 23, 2020
  16. buy generic cialis February 26, 2020
  17. Pingback: albuterol inhaler April 21, 2020
  18. Pingback: ciprofloxacina April 22, 2020
  19. FalfTraill April 28, 2020
  20. Pingback: can i buy naltrexone over the counter April 29, 2020
  21. Egnejx o May 2, 2020
  22. Generic viagra us May 5, 2020
  23. Us viagra May 6, 2020
  24. Order viagra us May 8, 2020
  25. Pingback: tylenol stock price May 8, 2020
  26. Buy viagra brand May 12, 2020
  27. Esthertup May 13, 2020
  28. Esthertup May 14, 2020
  29. cialis order online May 18, 2020
  30. chloroquine drug May 18, 2020
  31. mens erection pills May 21, 2020
  32. Johnny Danco May 22, 2020
  33. Dan Ioni May 22, 2020
  34. impotence pills May 23, 2020
  35. ed pills otc May 24, 2020
  36. best ed pills at gnc May 26, 2020
  37. Dan Danco May 27, 2020
  38. Candy Ioni May 28, 2020
  39. cheapest ed pills May 28, 2020
  40. buy hydroxychloroquine May 30, 2020
  41. Esthertup May 31, 2020
  42. Johnny Ioni June 1, 2020
  43. Candy Pulica June 2, 2020
  44. Genny Shovo June 3, 2020
  45. Dan Ioni June 3, 2020
  46. Candy Shovo June 3, 2020
  47. Dan Pulica June 5, 2020
  48. Andrei Carreyc June 5, 2020
  49. Mandela Carreyd June 7, 2020
  50. buy tadalafil 20 mg June 8, 2020
  51. Sarah Carreyc June 8, 2020
  52. Sarah Elizahc June 8, 2020
  53. Esthertup June 9, 2020
  54. Sarah Johnese June 10, 2020
  55. Esthertup June 11, 2020
  56. cephalexin 500mg June 11, 2020
  57. Esthertup June 11, 2020
  58. Geamanu Carreyb June 12, 2020
  59. Geamanu Carreyc June 12, 2020
  60. Andrei Elizahe June 13, 2020
  61. Esthertup June 13, 2020
  62. Esthertup June 14, 2020
  63. bimatoprost cost June 14, 2020
  64. Esthertup June 14, 2020
  65. Esthertup June 15, 2020
  66. Esthertup June 16, 2020
  67. Sarah Johnesa June 16, 2020
  68. Esthertup June 17, 2020
  69. Esthertup June 18, 2020
  70. Esthertup June 18, 2020
  71. Viagra or cialis June 19, 2020
  72. US viagra sales June 20, 2020
  73. Candy Ioni June 20, 2020
  74. Canadain viagra June 21, 2020
  75. Candy Ioni June 21, 2020
  76. Genny Danco June 21, 2020
  77. Sample viagra June 21, 2020
  78. Dan Danco June 21, 2020
  79. Candy Danco June 22, 2020
  80. Johnny Shovo June 22, 2020
  81. Michaelsnaxy June 22, 2020
  82. Johnny Danco June 22, 2020
  83. Michaelsnaxy June 22, 2020
  84. Johnny Ioni June 22, 2020
  85. Buy viagra now online June 22, 2020
  86. Michaelsnaxy June 22, 2020
  87. Buy viagra on internet June 22, 2020
  88. wbc247 June 23, 2020
  89. sex June 23, 2020
  90. Buy viagra lowest price June 24, 2020
  91. 샌즈카지노 June 24, 2020
  92. Candy Ioni June 24, 2020
  93. Candy Danco June 24, 2020
  94. Buy now viagra June 25, 2020
  95. http://whymestudios.com June 25, 2020
  96. Buy online viagra June 26, 2020
  97. 우리계열카지노 June 27, 2020
  98. Viagra alternative June 27, 2020
  99. Johnny Pulica June 27, 2020
  100. Best viagra alternative June 27, 2020
  101. sakib June 28, 2020
  102. bedroom design June 28, 2020
  103. Dan Danco June 28, 2020
  104. Candy Danco June 28, 2020
  105. Canada viagra June 28, 2020
  106. Dan Ioni June 28, 2020
  107. Genny Shovo June 28, 2020
  108. Genny Shovo June 28, 2020
  109. tadalafil 5mg June 28, 2020
  110. Dan Pulica June 29, 2020
  111. Pingback: safe to buy viagra online June 29, 2020
  112. Usa pharmacy viagra June 29, 2020
  113. marele pescar June 30, 2020
  114. free itunes gift card June 30, 2020
  115. global June 30, 2020
  116. Buy brand viagra June 30, 2020
  117. salty biscuit June 30, 2020
  118. Generic viagra us July 1, 2020
  119. Canadian viagra 50mg July 2, 2020
  120. blog July 2, 2020
  121. pujcky July 2, 2020
  122. Johnny Shovod July 3, 2020
  123. Johnny Shovon July 3, 2020
  124. Dan Ionih July 3, 2020
  125. Get viagra July 3, 2020
  126. b2b data providers uk July 3, 2020
  127. Genny Pulicaa July 3, 2020
  128. Robot Lawn Mower July 4, 2020
  129. buy cialis pills July 4, 2020
  130. sildenafil 100 July 4, 2020
  131. senzori pescuit July 4, 2020
  132. viagra prices July 6, 2020
  133. tadalafil cialis July 6, 2020
  134. generic cialis reviews July 6, 2020
  135. streaming rcti July 6, 2020
  136. streaming rcti July 6, 2020
  137. KRALOVNA July 6, 2020
  138. cialis tadalafil July 7, 2020
  139. online cialis July 7, 2020
  140. cialis 20 mg July 8, 2020
  141. Dan Pulicad July 8, 2020
  142. Sweets Pulicaa July 9, 2020
  143. Genny Dancoo July 9, 2020
  144. viagra dosage July 9, 2020
  145. cialis reviews July 9, 2020
  146. liquid tadalafil July 9, 2020
  147. หวย July 10, 2020
  148. หวย July 10, 2020
  149. หวย July 11, 2020
  150. cialis online pharmacy July 11, 2020
  151. Pingback: canadian healthcare viagra sales July 11, 2020
  152. WimCax July 11, 2020
  153. generic cialis 20mg July 11, 2020
  154. escort July 12, 2020
  155. furosemida July 13, 2020
  156. test 31 31 July 13, 2020
  157. seo July 14, 2020
  158. lasix tablet July 14, 2020
  159. Coco Diaria July 14, 2020
  160. lasix furosemide 40 mg July 15, 2020
  161. articole pescuit July 15, 2020
  162. afk arena hack generator July 16, 2020
  163. mafia city cheats July 16, 2020
  164. b2b email database July 17, 2020
  165. buy cialis online cheap July 17, 2020
  166. india car news July 17, 2020
  167. Casinosuilk July 17, 2020
  168. WimCax July 18, 2020
  169. cialis generic July 18, 2020
  170. weight loss tips July 19, 2020
  171. taşınabilir wifi July 20, 2020
  172. müzik dinle July 20, 2020
  173. müzik dinle July 20, 2020
  174. Modu Coconel July 20, 2020
  175. müzik dinle July 20, 2020
  176. edirne escort July 20, 2020
  177. free instagram followers July 20, 2020
  178. tadalafil 10 mg July 20, 2020
  179. instagram followers free July 20, 2020
  180. balıkesir escort bayan July 20, 2020
  181. manisa escort July 21, 2020
  182. Casinossuilk July 21, 2020
  183. 토토 July 21, 2020
  184. หวย July 21, 2020
  185. cialis 5 mg July 21, 2020
  186. 파워볼배팅 July 21, 2020
  187. Alexa July 21, 2020
  188. kamu personeli July 22, 2020
  189. car news July 22, 2020
  190. memur alımı July 22, 2020
  191. malatya escort July 22, 2020
  192. free b2b email database July 22, 2020
  193. indian auto news July 22, 2020
  194. cialis buy online July 22, 2020
  195. b2b email list July 23, 2020
  196. auto news July 23, 2020
  197. steam wallet codes free July 23, 2020
  198. Cullen Mihaita July 23, 2020
  199. Gorabet July 24, 2020
  200. online casino usa July 24, 2020
  201. Cullen Marin July 24, 2020
  202. NTVsporbet July 24, 2020
  203. Andy Cucubau July 24, 2020
  204. online gambling July 25, 2020
  205. cialis coupon July 26, 2020
  206. generic cialis online July 26, 2020
  207. free v bucks ios July 28, 2020
  208. WimCax July 28, 2020
  209. eski para koleksiyonu July 28, 2020
  210. buy real cialis online July 29, 2020
  211. Andy Andrei July 29, 2020
  212. Cullen Andrei July 29, 2020
  213. Gulas Andrei July 29, 2020
  214. sakarya escort July 29, 2020
  215. cialis cialis generic July 31, 2020
  216. vbucks free fortnite July 31, 2020
  217. tadalafil 20mg July 31, 2020
  218. porno izle August 1, 2020
  219. fortnite free vbucks August 1, 2020
  220. how to get free robux August 1, 2020
  221. how to get free vbucks August 1, 2020
  222. free the vbucks August 1, 2020
  223. tadalafil vs sildenafil August 2, 2020
  224. generic cialis online August 4, 2020
  225. psn codes free August 4, 2020
  226. Didel Dudulesc August 4, 2020
  227. Marinel Ciocan August 4, 2020
  228. buy viagra online cheap August 5, 2020
  229. buy generic viagra August 5, 2020
  230. telegram grup August 6, 2020
  231. kıbrıs gece hayatı August 7, 2020
  232. WimCax August 7, 2020
  233. vardenafil online August 7, 2020
  234. purchase viagra August 7, 2020
  235. Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine online August 8, 2020
  236. robux generator August 9, 2020
  237. free robux codes August 9, 2020
  238. free vbucks generator August 9, 2020
  239. free robux generator August 9, 2020
  240. robux generator August 9, 2020
  241. robux generator August 10, 2020
  242. levitra dosage August 10, 2020
  243. generic viagra reviews August 10, 2020
  244. online casino games August 12, 2020
  245. casino real money August 12, 2020
  246. januvia 25mg coupon August 12, 2020
  247. Adalberto Perigo August 12, 2020
  248. free robux codes August 12, 2020
  249. buy cialis August 13, 2020
  250. Metin2 pvp serverler blog August 13, 2020
  251. where to buy careprost August 14, 2020
  252. levitra dosage August 14, 2020
  253. real money casino August 14, 2020
  254. ownen August 14, 2020
  255. vegas casino online August 16, 2020
  256. online vardenafil August 16, 2020
  257. Gwenn Grater August 16, 2020
  258. WimCax August 17, 2020
  259. Kurtköy escort August 17, 2020
  260. maltepe escort August 17, 2020
  261. pendik escort August 18, 2020
  262. Teddy Poyo August 18, 2020
  263. free xbox live codes August 18, 2020
  264. free xbox live codes August 18, 2020
  265. free xbox codes August 19, 2020
  266. cialis c20 August 19, 2020
  267. solar enerji sistemleri August 19, 2020
  268. buy tadalafil August 19, 2020
  269. tadalafil cialis August 19, 2020
  270. itunes free codes August 19, 2020
  271. free itunes codes August 19, 2020
  272. itunes free codes August 20, 2020
  273. itunes free codes August 20, 2020
  274. bsooicelm August 20, 2020
  275. Andy Mihaita2 August 20, 2020
  276. Gulas Mihaitah August 20, 2020
  277. Andy Andreic August 20, 2020
  278. Castro Cucubau8 August 20, 2020
  279. zdrave bukvarche August 21, 2020
  280. vbucks generator August 21, 2020
  281. free vbucks August 21, 2020
  282. free vbucks generator August 21, 2020
  283. fast custom essay August 21, 2020
  284. how to get free vbucks August 21, 2020
  285. free vbucks generator August 21, 2020
  286. free v bucks August 21, 2020
  287. vbucks free August 21, 2020
  288. Hilde Luderman August 22, 2020
  289. viagra prices August 23, 2020
  290. senzori pescuit August 23, 2020
  291. ed meds August 23, 2020
  292. viagra cost August 24, 2020
  293. maltepe escort August 25, 2020
  294. Ataşehir escort August 25, 2020
  295. Technology August 25, 2020
  296. ümraniye escort August 25, 2020
  297. viagra canada August 26, 2020
  298. straight hemp cbd oil August 26, 2020
  299. non prescription viagra August 26, 2020
  300. cbd oil pdf August 27, 2020
  301. click here August 27, 2020
  302. tadalafil cialis August 27, 2020
  303. order cialis online August 27, 2020
  304. side effects cbd oil drops August 28, 2020
  305. thesis binding August 28, 2020
  306. Pingback: buy viagra online cheap August 28, 2020
  307. fbbkTranY August 28, 2020
  308. bfnhbBoync August 28, 2020
  309. best erection pills August 28, 2020
  310. Berryspemy August 28, 2020
  311. bsbnjoymn August 28, 2020
  312. vsvhjoymn August 29, 2020
  313. ibogaine online August 29, 2020
  314. cialis buy cialis online August 29, 2020
  315. cheap thesis binding August 29, 2020
  316. bsbhJuign August 29, 2020
  317. cialis 10mg August 29, 2020
  318. best generic viagra August 29, 2020
  319. bsbbgduelt August 29, 2020
  320. how to cheat pokemon go August 29, 2020
  321. generic viagra August 29, 2020
  322. Pingback: cheapest generic viagra August 29, 2020
  323. Berryspemy August 29, 2020
  324. go to my site August 30, 2020
  325. 테니스 베팅 August 30, 2020
  326. Scottped August 30, 2020
  327. kosembol August 30, 2020
  328. viagra alternative August 30, 2020
  329. free psn gift card codes August 31, 2020
  330. bsjknaing August 31, 2020
  331. brawl stars hack August 31, 2020
  332. free xbox gift card August 31, 2020
  333. coinmaster free spins August 31, 2020
  334. Pingback: viagra pill August 31, 2020
  335. nhjuTranY August 31, 2020
  336. robux generator August 31, 2020
  337. purchase clomid August 31, 2020
  338. 예스벳88 August 31, 2020
  339. vbucks generator August 31, 2020
  340. bsrcxJuign August 31, 2020
  341. 안전카지노 August 31, 2020
  342. muikjoymn August 31, 2020
  343. customized essay August 31, 2020
  344. order custom paper August 31, 2020
  345. ikiykBoync August 31, 2020
  346. Scottped September 1, 2020
  347. kidfajoymn September 1, 2020
  348. order essay online cheap September 1, 2020
  349. propecia cost September 1, 2020
  350. help with thesis writing September 1, 2020
  351. best dissertation service September 1, 2020
  352. dhgbgduelt September 1, 2020
  353. viagra 100mg September 1, 2020
  354. Pingback: buying generic viagra online September 1, 2020
  355. generic cialis online September 1, 2020
  356. buy cheap viagra September 2, 2020
  357. Cullen Mihaitag September 2, 2020
  358. 카지노 룰렛 September 2, 2020
  359. baccarat September 3, 2020
  360. Pingback: viagra samples September 3, 2020
  361. order viagra September 3, 2020
  362. RalphGob September 3, 2020
  363. 카지노 사이트 September 3, 2020
  364. Tanisha Delpaggio September 4, 2020
  365. ilmaiset pornovideot September 4, 2020
  366. Carey Reznicek September 4, 2020
  367. RalphGob September 4, 2020
  368. best online casino for money September 4, 2020
  369. Pingback: buy viagra in chicago September 4, 2020
  370. best online casino real money September 4, 2020
  371. jackpot party casino September 4, 2020
  372. Pingback: buy viagra new york September 5, 2020
  373. see this here mercurycards.com September 5, 2020
  374. india car news September 6, 2020
  375. building envelope solutions September 6, 2020
  376. coin master free spins links September 6, 2020
  377. Vernonrom September 6, 2020
  378. Alan Romm September 6, 2020
  379. Tarachny September 6, 2020
  380. real money online casino September 7, 2020
  381. nettkasinot September 7, 2020
  382. Pingback: buy viagra pills September 7, 2020
  383. 슬롯 September 7, 2020
  384. kluki September 7, 2020
  385. about September 7, 2020
  386. de addiction center in chennai September 7, 2020
  387. Granvilleflve September 7, 2020
  388. pills erectile dysfunction September 8, 2020
  389. goodrx cialis September 8, 2020
  390. Vernonrom September 8, 2020
  391. Kaleighcfef September 8, 2020
  392. Martin Andrei3 September 8, 2020
  393. Nganfkxs September 8, 2020
  394. have a peek at this web-site September 8, 2020
  395. Privatedogtraining.net September 8, 2020
  396. Ingeujfo September 9, 2020
  397. Alysoncvtj September 9, 2020
  398. Lillianaqbll September 9, 2020
  399. Brenda Delsol September 9, 2020
  400. Linocipa September 9, 2020
  401. roof repair toronto September 9, 2020
  402. kevin david course September 9, 2020
  403. Private Dog Training September 9, 2020
  404. generic cialis tadalafil September 9, 2020
  405. tadalafil citrate September 9, 2020
  406. Lettyyvqj September 9, 2020
  407. Vernonrom September 9, 2020
  408. Suzietgtw September 9, 2020
  409. AAminue September 9, 2020
  410. Karmaxfax September 9, 2020
  411. how to write an about me essay September 9, 2020
  412. Bridgettelee September 9, 2020
  413. free slots online September 9, 2020
  414. college paper help September 9, 2020
  415. data resellers usa September 10, 2020
  416. check this link right here now September 10, 2020
  417. see this September 10, 2020
  418. best psychiatric hospitals September 10, 2020
  419. india car news September 10, 2020
  420. tow truck las vegas nm September 10, 2020
  421. auto news September 10, 2020
  422. Best B2B Marketplaces in India September 10, 2020
  423. Mitzieqqiy September 10, 2020
  424. cvs retail sildenafil 100 mg September 11, 2020
  425. free coinmaster spins September 11, 2020
  426. free spins coin master September 11, 2020
  427. free coin master spins September 11, 2020
  428. free spins coin master September 11, 2020
  429. drone cat September 11, 2020
  430. Margodqlc September 11, 2020
  431. istanbul escort September 11, 2020
  432. free coin master spins September 11, 2020
  433. cheap seo services September 11, 2020
  434. Isaias Griffard September 11, 2020
  435. pendik escort September 11, 2020
  436. Aaronposg September 11, 2020
  437. Anibal Jex September 11, 2020
  438. şehirler arası nakliyat September 11, 2020
  439. Jimmynocj September 11, 2020
  440. his comment is here September 12, 2020
  441. useful reference September 12, 2020
  442. jonathan manzi September 12, 2020
  443. internetten para kazan September 12, 2020
  444. vedonlyöntivihjeet September 12, 2020
  445. Mila Poteat September 12, 2020
  446. Technology Users email list September 12, 2020
  447. Brianadlzu September 12, 2020
  448. Erma Mcglew September 12, 2020
  449. Linghtvc September 12, 2020
  450. b2b business database September 12, 2020
  451. order viagra September 12, 2020
  452. ThomasKidic September 12, 2020
  453. levitra vardenafil September 12, 2020
  454. Selmabbsf September 12, 2020
  455. Mitsuepdyn September 13, 2020
  456. 24 7 electrician Perth September 13, 2020
  457. ThomasKidic September 13, 2020
  458. Carononvm September 13, 2020
  459. Harleygzdb September 13, 2020
  460. Askyday September 13, 2020
  461. Darleen Quintel September 13, 2020
  462. female viagra September 13, 2020
  463. Thomasenaqtkl September 13, 2020
  464. nail designs video September 14, 2020
  465. canada viagra September 14, 2020
  466. 마카오카지노 September 14, 2020
  467. Puerto Rico Caribbean September 14, 2020
  468. la hookup September 14, 2020
  469. Puerto Rico Travel 2020 September 14, 2020
  470. ThomasKidic September 14, 2020
  471. Puerto Rico Caribbean September 14, 2020
  472. Puerto Rico Hotels September 14, 2020
  473. Mattress Cover India September 14, 2020
  474. viagra sample September 14, 2020
  475. Chester Broce September 14, 2020
  476. is sildenafil a drug substance September 15, 2020
  477. Loyceshpr September 15, 2020
  478. click more September 15, 2020
  479. ThomasKidic September 15, 2020
  480. torso sex doll September 15, 2020
  481. Puerto Rico Things to Do September 15, 2020
  482. amazon advertising portfolios September 15, 2020
  483. Puerto Rico Travel 2020 September 15, 2020
  484. Stephniezdkl September 15, 2020
  485. netflix account generator September 15, 2020
  486. scottish currency September 15, 2020